Boxycharm went dark and mysterious with the theme of their October box! Everything was black and intense. You ready to see all the fun products included in this month’s box? Let’s get right into it, then!
How BoxyCharm Works!
It’s really easy! Just 3 totally-simple steps.
- Join now and receive 4-5 full-size beauty products for $21/month plus free shipping! ($100+ on average value each month)
- Explore your beauty and experience your new products with tutorials and looks shared by our community of Charmers.
- Enjoy exclusive members-only offers from the best brands in beauty, win free products through BOXY-Giveaways, and receive rewards for being a Charmer!
What’s in my BoxyCharm October Box!
If you’ve never signed up for a beauty subscription box, it’s like getting a birthday present in the mail every month! It’s awesome! This month’s box was all the many different ‘faces’ of you. ๐ I thought it was very appropriate considering Halloween is right around the corner now. I was actually surprised there wasn’t anything really different or intriguing about this box. While everything has black packaging, you’ll see that not much can be used to ‘create’ any sort of costume. But I’m getting ahead of myself, let’s look at the first product!
Doucce Punk Volumizer Mascara // Full Size // This mascara is supposed to give you separation, length, and lots of volume. I definitely agree with the claims of this mascara. I was surprised and pleased to see that it didn’t clump my lashes together and gave me nice volume and length. It will flake a bit throughout the day, and if you rub your eyes, so keep that in mind. It wasn’t anything out-of-this-world volumizing, but definitely a mascara that I will get a lot of use out of for an every day mascara.
Palmetto Derma Rejuvenating Antioxidant Mask // Full Size // I love getting expensive skincare in my subscription boxes because it lets me try something I otherwise probably would never have purchased. With this mask, I wanted to like it….but I found that the fragrance was too strong. And scents don’t typically bother me, but with this mask I felt it was giving me the wrong ‘tingle’ on the skin, due to the fragrance. I didn’t experience any negative results from using this once (which is good) but I’m not sure if I’ll be trying it again anytime soon.
Cult Cosmetics Nail Polish in Boneyards // Full Size // I love a good nail polish — especially one in this color. It’s very fall/winter appropriate, in my book. I couldn’t wait to get it on my nails! The quality of this polish is great. Two coats is all you need and the color is opaque and beautiful. I like this polish and will use it a lot this winter!
Bellapierre Cheek and Lip Stain in Coral // Full Size // I’m honestly not much of a cream face product type of gal, so I couldn’t get super-excited about this product. But I did give it a try! I applied it both to my lips and cheeks and….I just found it too waxy to ever really set. And the color is so light, I couldn’t detect any type of staining. Maybe it’d be nicer for a gal just getting into makeup to play around with — I plan to pass this on to my younger sisters to use as they start their ‘makeup journey’, but I honestly wasn’t very impressed.
Lord & Berry Line/Shade Eyeliner in Dark Black // Full Size // I love a good eyeliner, and have heard of this line before so was excited and curious to see how this turned out. The formula is very black and creamy, and when used as a base and blended out, it works well — as long as you set it with a shadow. If you don’t set this (say you’re just lining your eyes or putting it in your waterline)….this is definitely going to move, smudge, crease and come off if touched. And I let it ‘set’ on my eyes half the morning! I don’t know how they can claim this is waterproof. P:-/ But I did find it had a faint staining effect — to remove the color completely from my hands/eyes soap and water didn’t cut it.
Here are swatches of the eye liner and lip/cheek stain. As you can see, the Lord & Berry liner was very creamy and opaque, which is what I look for in a liner, but not sure how much use I will get out of it since it doesn’t set well. And the stain was a pretty color, if you’re into cream face products.
The Value of my October Box
Math time! Let’s see how much this BoxyCharm October box was worth!
- Palmetto Derma Mask — $64
- Doucce Punk Mascara — $24
- Bellapierre Cheek & Lip Stain — $19.99
- Lord & Berry Eyeliner — $18
- Cult Cosmetics Nail Polish — $12
TOTAL = $137.99
As usual, the value of their box exceeds $100, which is impressive. I wish the contents of the box were a little more exciting, a little more fall or Halloween themed, but I did like the all-black aspect of it. ๐
Check out past BoxyCharm Unboxing Posts!
What do you think of this month’s box? Which item was your favorite? Did you have different results using these products than I did?
PIN IT! SAVE IT!
I received the products mentioned above from BoxyCharm in the hopes that I would mention them on my blog. Regardless, this does not guarantee a review or feature on my blog. I only share information that I think will be useful for my readers and I only recommend products I have personally used.
Christine says
Awesome box in my opinion! it seems like you got so much value for what you spent!! That’s always a good sign of a subscription and also if you’re able to use most of the products!!
Katie Garvin says
Yes, that’s so true — I’ve been really loving getting full-size products that I can either use or can gift to a friend! ๐
Tess says
I have a lot of trouble with cream blushes. I love how easy they are to apply and how they look, but some of them just suck! I’ve been using one from NYX a lot lately and it’s really good.
Katie Garvin says
I’ve never been really good at using cream blushes, either! But the only way it works for me to apply them is with the ELF small stipple brush and setting it with a powder on top. I’ll have to check out NYX’s cream blushes soon, thanks!
Allison @neversaydiebeauty says
I’ve had good experiences with Lord & Berry and Bellapierre products from ipsy. I love the look of the cheek & lip stain in particular!
Katie Garvin says
L&B was new to me, but I’ve gotten Bellapierre products in the past, an eyeshadow to be exact, and I really liked it!
whatlauraloves says
Oooh that lip and cheek stain is sooooo pretty xxxx
Katie Garvin says
The color IS pretty ๐
Renu says
Any box that sends out a mascara, a lip and cheek stain and a polish is brilliant in my book! This is one of the best subs out there.
Katie Garvin says
Renu, I agree, it’s pretty-darn bomb! ๐
Kristina says
Thats too bad about the mask, I’ve heard mostly negative things about it. ๐ That lip & cheek stain is super pretty though!
Katie Garvin says
I haven’t looked up reviews, but not too surprised to hear that. I didn’t enjoy the experience, lol ๐
Maria Gridley says
I think this months box was great, though I am with you – I do think a few more exciting things would have been nice! Still I am always super impressed with my boxycharm box! Its always an amazing deal for the price of the box!
Katie Garvin says
Yeah, the value was great, but nothing that made my makeup-obsessed heart jumped at. We’ll see what next month holds! ๐
veena says
I think my favorite from this box is the lip stain.
Katie Garvin says
Veena, it’ll be so pretty to have handy in the spring. Perfect color ๐
Laura says
The value of the box is fantastic and there is nice selection of products as well ๐
Laura
Pink Frenzy
Katie Garvin says
Laura, I’m always super pleased with the value of Boxycharm boxes!
Alice says
I love that they themed the box for halloween!! ๐ black is my favortie color ๐
Katie Garvin says
It was fun! I’m always curious to see what the theme will be for each box each month ๐
Rachel says
This is a great box, especially for October with those darker shades x
Katie Garvin says
Yes, very very true Rachel ๐
Esha says
Now that’s a box to try! Loved the coral stain.
Katie Garvin says
Give it a try sometime! ๐
Jess says
This would be a bit of a ‘meh’ box for me I think, there doesn’t look to be anything particularly exciting! I like the sound of the mask, what a shame about the fragrance…
Jess xo