
More About Boxycharm
Just in case youβve never heard of BoxyCharm before, let me give you a quick rundown of how it works! For only $21 a month, BoxyCharm ships out a box filled with 4-5 full size products. The value of each box is typically around or well over $100 each month. And shipping is free! So itβs like an Ispy, but 10 times better! Iβve received products from new-to-me brands as well as popular, high end brands, too! Itβs a great way to discover new products at an affordable price!
What’s in my September Boxycharm Box









The Value of My September Box
Okay, who’s ready to add up these prices with me?
- Previse Skincare HydroMilk Hydrating Lotion – $48
- Vasanti Professional Foundation Brush – $32
- tarte smolderEYES Amazonian Clay Waterproof Liner – $22
- Chella Eyebrow Defining Gel – $18
- SCRATCH Nail Wraps – $12
- Kardashian Beauty Black Seed Dry Oil – Travel Size
TOTAL = $132
So, as usual with BoxyCharm boxes, the value of the box is well over $100! The contents of the box weren’t the most exciting, for me, so I can’t say this is my favorite box (last month’s box is definitely still my fav!), but still fun to get. I can’t believe the retail price of the brush and brow gel — overpriced, in my opinion! Or maybe I just really got a dud with that brush… But I’ll definitely be putting the liner and brow gel to good use!
Look at Past Boxycharm Unboxings!
PIN IT! SAVE IT!

I received the products mentioned above from BoxyCharm in the hopes that I would mention them on my blog. Regardless, this does not guarantee a review or feature on my blog. I only share information that I think will be useful for my readers and I only recommend products I have personally used.

WhatLauraLoves says
Not my favourite box from Boxycharm but I ADORE the look of the Tarte liner. Great post as always honey xxx
Katie Garvin says
Yeah, I hear ya — wasn’t my favorite either. But I’ll definitely use the Tarte liner.I think it’s the perfect color for fall. And I can always use a clear brow gel! So at least it wasn’t a total disappointment π
Jamie | Makeup Life and Love says
Ok so I totally NEED boxy charm. Each time I read a review I am in awe of the goodies, lately Ipsy and Birchbox have been not so hot in my eyes, so this for sure might be what I need to add to my subscription box addiction. Great box and thanks for sharing!
Katie Garvin says
Go for it, girl! For only $21 a box, the value is amazing! Every time I do the math (just check out my previous unboxings!) the value is always around or (more often) over $100! And even if they include products I can’t use, they make awesome gifts because they’re full size!
Kate Flower says
That Tarte eyeliner is gorgeous! Definitely the stand out item ?
Katie Garvin says
Yes, I agree π
Rachel says
It is an interesting mixture of products, but I am with you on the lack of excitement x
Katie Garvin says
Yeah, nothing really ‘got me giddy’ this month (except maybe the Tarte liner), but last month’s box was filled with lots of items I have been using on the daily!
HilLesha says
I love Tarte Cosmetics! The color of the waterproof liner is so beautiful and shimmery! I’ll have to check it out for sure.
Katie Garvin says
Oh yes! Every Tarte product I’ve ever tried, I’ve loved. π
Christine says
I’d have to say not my favorite box that I’ve seen, but that Tarte liner is gorgeous! What a great color for some Fall makeup looks!
Katie Garvin says
I know, I’m looking forward to using it for a fall eyeshadow look! π
Allison @neversaydiebeauty says
I agree with the others: not the best of the Boxycharm boxes, but the Tarte eye crayon is gorgeous. I also love Chella, though I don’t need more brow gel, lol.
Katie Garvin says
I’d never heard of the brand Chella before — good to hear you like them, though! Maybe I’ll check out more from them after I use this up π
Anna @ The Beauty Section says
That Tarte eye crayon looks so pretty, that to me looks like the best thing in the box. I like certain nail wraps, but those look kind of blah haha!
Katie Garvin says
Yeah, I agree — I’m so-so when it comes to nail wraps, but the design just didn’t jump out and grab me. And I typically like brown, lol. But my sisters will enjoy playing with them π
Tess says
I was thinking that brush looked good for face masks before I even read about it! Hah. I use a similar brush to apply masks but want one a little bigger, this looks like a good size!
Katie Garvin says
Haha, too funny! Yes, that’s the only thing I use paddle brushes for! π The brush I was using before was getting old, cracked, and loose, so the timing was great to replace it with this brush π
Kristina says
I have heard a lot of good things about the Tarte Smoldereyes, but too bad about that Vasanti brush…
Katie Garvin says
Yeah, I’ve heard good things, too. And the swatch set pretty nicely on my arm. The brush actually worked well for my face mask this past week, so not a total dud! π
Laura says
This looks amazing! I wish we would get this amazing boxes here! My last Style Tone box was amazing though π
Laura
Pink Frenzy
Katie Garvin says
Aww, sorry girl! Glad you have a subscription box that’s worth getting, though! Subscription boxes are SO much fun to get! It’s like your birthday every month π
Jess says
This looks like such a great box, I probably wouldn’t use the nail wraps either but everything else looks fab! The Tarte liner is such a pretty shade <3
Jess xo
Katie Garvin says
I know, I can’t wait to use the Tarte liner! π