NYX Cosmetics released their new Ultimate Shadow Palettes a few weeks ago and everyone instantly connected them visually as looking like the popular Viseart palettes. These palettes are on the more expensive end for NYX, but I was able to get them on sale during a ‘Buy One Get One Half Off” and use a 20% off Ulta coupon on top of that. Much more affordable! But are they worth it?
Sadly, I don’t own any of the Viseart palettes to do a comparison. Sorry! I kind of assumed those who do own them would do a comparison, but if you’re not seeing any comparison posts, let me know and I’ll be happy to purchase them and create a “Dupe or Dud” post for you! 😉
Purchased by MeAffiliate Links
NYX Ultimate Shadow Palettes
Retail Price: $17.99 | Click for More Info
I just picked up two of the four new Ultimate shadow palettes — the Warm Neutrals and the Brights palette. Each palette contains 16 shadows, so your paying just a little over a dollar each shade. One thing that I find very annoying is that the palettes are very difficult to open when snapped shut. Once I even grabbed my tweezers just to pop it open!
The Warm Neutrals Ultimate Shadow palette has nine mattes and seven shimmers. A nice mix, in my opinion. I like that they made sure to include light matte shades for the brow bone and dark matte shades for smoking out the outer corner. I do wish that they had one dark brown shade. The deepest color is a grayish/brown that doesn’t give me the deep color I want (like the matte brown in the LORAC PRO Palette).
The Brights Ultimate Shadow palette has about the same range of mattes and shimmers, but I actually find that only about three of the shimmer shades actually show up looking like shimmer. The others look shimmery in the pan, but when used on the lids it’s difficult to detect. Which is nice! I prefer matte shadows, and if I ever want to add sparkle to my bright eye looks I can just top it with a glitter. 🙂
Ready to look at swatches? As always, these are swatched twice without any primer underneath.
As you can see, the Warm Neutrals palette has a nice variety of shades that have great pigmentation. A few of the shades like the two goldish shimmers on the top right and the matte gray/brown on the bottom right were kind of a dud, but can be made to work. I thought that last gray/brown shade was a little weird in this palette, anyway, as it comes off as cool-tone to me….and I didn’t get the cool tone palette, haha!
Here are three looks that I created using this palette. The gold eye palette I actually pulled a true, dark, warm grown to use in the outer edge. But everything else was shades from the Warm Neutrals Ultimate Shadow palettes! I loved the middle copper color. It was stunning! And showed up a lot more shimmery in person!
I think you can see what I was talking about the shimmery shades not really showing up very shimmery when swatched. All the colors swatch beautifully — with the exception of the bright yellow one in the bottom right hand corner. There was a good big of powder kick up when swatching them, but I found that when I tapped my brush off before using it on my eyes, I had barely any fall out.
And here are three looks I created using this palette! If you didn’t know, I am a big neutrals/brown lover, so all of these looks were way outside my comfort zone…but totally fun! All the colors were pretty easy to blend and use…except for that yellow shade. It gave me so much trouble! With all of these looks I used either a nude or white base to get them to show up really vibrant. If you don’t use a base, you’ll get a much softer (and more wearable) look. Which, depending on what you’re looking for, you may or may not like. 🙂
By the way, the look all the way on the right was inspired by Vintage or Tacky on Youtube, love the look she created!
So do I recommend the Ultimate Shadow palettes or not, that is the question! I would say that the Warm Neutrals palette is definitely worth picking up. I find myself reaching for it often and I’ve already made a dent in the first matte brow bone shade at the top! The Brights palette, now that one is a little harder to say… I am glad I have it in my collection and it can work to create really great looks — it may just need more prep/work. I would say that if you don’t wear bright colors often, this will be the perfect palette for you to purchase and have whenever you feel adventurous.
But if you’re the type of makeup artist that enjoys going bold and dramatic often, I think it might be more worth your while to save up for either the Urban Decay Electric palette or the Viseart Brights palette. That’s just my two cents on the matter, though! 😉
Have you purchased any of the new Ultimate Shadow palettes yet? If so, which ones and what do you think of them? If not…which do you want to get first? 😉
Was this Review Helpful? Share this Pin with Friends! Thank you!
I purchased all products on my own. I was not compensated for writing this post. Some affiliate links are used above, meaning I get a few cents when you click through them. All thoughts are 100% my own. Any questions about my disclosure, read here. 
Thank you for your support!
Kristina | The Feminine Files says
These sound good for the price, but I LOATHE palettes that are hard to open. I love all of the looks you did…so gorgeous and perfect!
Katie Garvin says
I hear you — it got a bit frustrating a few times. After a while I just stopped clicking it shut all the way, lol
Chelsie Carr says
Thanks for reviewing these! I’ve been seeing them pop up all over my feed, so I’ve been interested to see how they swatched! I don’t think I’d buy them, just because I would rather spend a little bit more and buy something from Too Faced
Katie Garvin says
It IS a high price for a drugstore palette, but its a large palette and a better deal if you can get them on sale! 🙂
Melissa says
The looks you did with this is amazing!
Katie Garvin says
Thank you!! <3
MarciaF says
Having that bright palette would be a good inexpensive way to have colors I’d wear just a few times.
Katie Garvin says
Yeah, that was my thinking as well! 🙂
Nina says
Wow!!!! That one palette is insane!!!
Katie Garvin says
I know, right?! So vibrant!
Kristi V Beginnails says
I’m such a neutral gal, but I am totally digging the bright palette! I love the looks you created with them! Great review!
Katie Garvin says
I am a neutral girl, too, but do enjoy some crazy bright eyes on occasion…when I’m alone, haha!
Renu says
LOOK at all those vibrant shades! I doubt I can pull off those yellows and lime greens but all three of your EOTDs are amazing.
Katie Garvin says
Aww, thank you girl! Youd be surprised what you can pull off — I never thought I would like these vibrant eyes…but it was fun!
Shilpa Gandotra says
Love both the palettes – and what you did using them !
Katie Garvin says
Thanks, glad you like them!
ellesees.net says
thanks for the review and all ofthe hard work!! i think i’ll skip these–i can’t believe i’m passing up palettes, lol. love the looks you did!
Katie Garvin says
Haha, I know, every time I see a palette — I don’t care what brand! — I’m like “NEED” 😛
Emily Draher says
This is a great review! I feel like I’d be really drawn to the Brights palette and then have no idea what to do with it – so your looks are great inspo!!
Katie Garvin says
Glad you found them helpful! Pinterest is AMAZING for inspiration — that’s where I went 😀
Nichole C says
those brights! I love the vivid colors.
Katie Garvin says
I know, they’re so vibrant!
Michaela - The Mani Café says
some of those neutrals look lovely!!
Katie Garvin says
They are! I’ve been reaching for it a lot recently 😀
Rachel says
I love the colourful palette, though I wouldnt use any of the shades, it is just beautiful x
Katie Garvin says
Hahaha, I know, part of me just wanted to own a palette with such vibrant colors. I’m glad I found a way to use them!
Ann says
These palettes are adorable!!! They remind me of those super expensive viseart palettes
Katie Garvin says
Yes, that’s exactly what I thought of, too!
Krystal E says
I’m surprised how well pigmented the Brights was on bare skin. Love both looks!
Katie Garvin says
Yeah, it was pretty impressive! Probably not as nice and creamy as a high end palette, but perfect if your looking for a palette to only use on occasion
Laura says
The nude palette is so pretty and I do like the brighter one as well, but I wouldn’t use it as much. I’m more nudes girl 😀
Katie Garvin says
I hear you, girl! I’m always drawn to the neutral colors 😀
Jess says
Oh wow, the Brights palette is STUNNING! I’m not sure I’d get much wear from it but it sure is pretty 😀
I love the third look you did with that one, so pretty 🙂
Jess xo
Katie Garvin says
It’s gorgeous, I love it! Thank you, I’m just glad they turned out well. I’ve never experimented with such bright colors!